Are prop firms a scam? (2024)

Prop firms aren’t the only way to scale up your trading… but they’re one of the fastest ways.

The thing is…

I’ve gotten comments like these over the past week:

“Nonsense! Prop firms are a scam, looking for traders who will pay for challenges and then fail. That’s how they make their $”

So I thought it’d be worth addressing it.

===

In case you weren’t aware of it…

Prop firms are companies that fund traders with certain rules once they pass an evaluation period.

(1) Why do they ask for an evaluation?

While there’s a sign up fee for it, prop firms can’t afford to risk capital on losing traders.

Back when I started trading in 2013, you could get a funded account but had to deposit $5k to cover your drawdown (5% on a $100k account).

Any loss would be taken on your “deposit”.

These days conditions are much better…

The sign up fee you pay (usually 1% of the account) helps cover those who get funded and blow up the account.

In many cases…

Once you’ve made a certain % on the account, the max drawdown is locked at the starting balance… so there’s no downside for the firm and they get paid from your profits.

You can make the returns you want collecting your profit share, but need to respect the rules (i.e. not lose too much).

It’s a good business model both for the trader who’s trading profitably… and the prop firm.

After all the prop firm gets paid too if you perform well… which is worth way more than just a sign up fee.

===

But I’m not saying all prop firms are legit though.

In the last year, some prop firms have closed whileothers have been accused of making trading conditions bad on purpose.

There's lots of bad apples making it look bad for everyone else 🙁

But that’s why picking a good prop firm who’s been around for a while… and backed by live capital is important.

And it’s always better not to put all your eggs in one basket.

Meaning, you can get accounts with multiple prop firms and diversify your funds.

===

Here are some other Qs you might be interested in:

(2) Why’s the max. drawdown so low?

While prop firms are offering a 5% to 7% max drawdown before the account gets terminated…. and some people are complaining about it, it’s really not uncommon in the trading industry.

Traders in big institutions have to stick to much stricter rules…

You can’t just get unlimited drawdown and expect no one will say a word if you blow up 20% of your account.

The easy way around it through is to reduce your risk per trade.

Yes, you’ll make less money… but you can focus on trading bigger account sizes.

(3) Why can’t I trade the news / over the week-end?

In most cases, that’s because trading during news events or holding trades over the week-end adds risk.

You get slippage during a news and could lose more than you anticipated.

There could also be a gap in the market after a week-end.

If you want to do these things and the prop firm incurs extra risk, they’ll let you do it… but might charge you a slightly higher sign up fee.

(4) What are my odds of passing?

From what I’ve gathered, nearly 90% of traders fail the prop firm evaluation they start.

It’s not that far off from the saying: *“95% of traders lose money.”*

But that’s because most of the traders who take on prop firm evaluations aren’t even profitable in the first place.

They’re hoping to get lucky…

I’ve been able to prove that with proper training and good trading strategies, that failure rate can get much lower.

Those who do what we teach in Ultimate Prop Firm Trading have an 80% chance of passing a prop firm evaluation on the first try.

Much better than the industry average of 10% 🙂

In the rare case they don’t pass…

I’ve got a guarantee of success with my program and will help them make it work the next time around.

And if I can’t, I refund them 🙂

===

This is what I do inside of Ultimate Prop Firm Trading

Not only will I teach you my proven strategies, build your mindset & funded traders skills

I’ll also pay for your first $25,000 prop firm evaluation once you’re ready… which if you pass, will be trading on real capital.

So if you want to join us and get funded 5-6 figures by a prop firm… on your way to a full-time income in 2024?

You'll get all the info you need to start below:

If you need a refresher, here's what you get by signing up now:

  • 9-module course to build professional trading skills
  • Complimentary prop firm challenge
  • Trading strategies with metrics prop firms will love
  • Risk management plan for prop trading
  • Monthly trader mastermind calls
  • Bonus #1: Complimentary $25k funded evaluation
  • Bonus #2: Pre-evaluation 1-1 coaching call
  • Bonus #3: Proven crypto strategy TradingView scripts

Keep crushing it 💪 📈

Are prop firms a scam? (2024)

FAQs

Are prop firms a scam? ›

Yes, prop firms do pay. While there are some scams out there popping up everyday, reputable prop trading firms like True Forex Funds, FTMO,5%ers,FundedNext are legitimate and pay traders according to their profit-sharing agreements.

Are prop firms reliable? ›

Yes, some prop firms are entirely legitimate! Concerns may arise as online prop firms are unregulated. As a result, scam firms do, unfortunately, appear. But this does not mean that all prop firms are illegitimate.

Is prop firm real or fake? ›

Prop businesses nowadays are utterly unregulated and far apart from the banking industry. As a result, these internet prop companies are legitimate and not a fraud. Scammers do exist in the sector, though, and they attempt to exploit the current market because there isn't much oversight.

Is prop trading a pyramid scheme? ›

Prop firms that give traders demo capital mirror the business models of pyramid schemes, making those a much higher risk. To limit these risks, work with a reputable, established prop firm that funds traders with real money.

Are you trading real money with prop firms? ›

All accounts given by the Prop Firm are DEMO accounts. You would not be trading REAL MONEY. All Prop Firms say this. You are not trading on the LIVE markets therefore you are not engaging in CFDs, Leverage, etc etc with a broker.

What happens if you lose money in a prop firm? ›

Proprietary trading firms often provide evaluation accounts where you prove your trading skills. Usually, you pay a one-time fee to enter this "challenge." If you lose money during this evaluation, you won't owe anything beyond the initial fee.

What is the success rate of prop traders? ›

According to it, 4% of traders, on average, pass prop firm challenges. But only 1% of traders kept their funded accounts for a reasonable amount of time. While this result is not nearly as bad as the one discussed earlier, it still looks bleak for prospective prop traders.

Which is the most trusted prop firm? ›

Best Prop Trading Firms 2024 - Reviewed by Experts
  • Topstep.
  • The 5%ers.
  • Earn2Trade.
  • SurgeTrader.
  • FTMO.
  • E8.
  • City Traders Imperium.
  • Fidelcrest.
Feb 2, 2024

Should you join a prop firm? ›

Joining a prop trading firm can provide access to cutting-edge technology and resources that individual traders may not have. Additionally, being part of a team can offer valuable mentorship, networking opportunities, and collaboration with like-minded professionals.

Can you make a living with prop trading? ›

Prop trading can be lucrative, with earnings tied to a profit-sharing ratio. Unlike traditional brokers relying on commissions, prop traders' income directly links to generated profits. Ratios vary, often ranging from 75/100 to 90/100, offering flexibility based on experience and strategy.

Is five rings a prop trading firm? ›

Five Rings is a proprietary trading firm founded with a vision of combining strategy, innovation and technology to succeed in today's global markets. Based in New York, we trade in various domestic and international markets, both established and esoteric. Five Rings does not depend on clients or outside investors.

Can you sue prop firm? ›

Consulting with a legal professional is crucial for tailored advice based on your specific circ*mstances. This information is not legal advice. Legal action can be taken against a broker or prop firm for trade manipulation or unfair practices, but success is not guaranteed.

How do prop firms pay you? ›

Traders can often withdraw their profits on a bi-weekly or monthly basis, providing them with a regular income stream. However, the frequency of withdrawals will vary depending on the prop firm and the trader's agreement with them.

How stressful is prop trading? ›

It's a competitive, high-stress field with drawbacks like any other career. It's also awash with less-than-reputable firms that offer zero base pay, limited profit sharing and often make new hires pay for training and tech. Avoid these types of firms as they're a ticket to plenty of risk with minimal reward.

What are the disadvantages of prop firms? ›

👎 Prop Trading Cons
  • Proprietary Firms Are Less Regulated Than Retail Brokers: Most prop trading firms that provide remote trading are not regulated at all. ...
  • Risk of Losing Money: ...
  • Proprietary Trading Fees are High: ...
  • Prop Trading is Mostly Day Trading: ...
  • Proprietary Firms Can Steal Your Intellectual Property:
Nov 15, 2023

What percentage do prop firms take? ›

A prop trading firm looks to recruit talented traders and fund them with the company's capital. The funds that a trader makes, is then split between the trader and the company. The profit share is between 50 – 95%, with the trader taking the lion's share.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Ray Christiansen

Last Updated:

Views: 5774

Rating: 4.9 / 5 (49 voted)

Reviews: 88% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Ray Christiansen

Birthday: 1998-05-04

Address: Apt. 814 34339 Sauer Islands, Hirtheville, GA 02446-8771

Phone: +337636892828

Job: Lead Hospitality Designer

Hobby: Urban exploration, Tai chi, Lockpicking, Fashion, Gunsmithing, Pottery, Geocaching

Introduction: My name is Ray Christiansen, I am a fair, good, cute, gentle, vast, glamorous, excited person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.